This website does not track your personal or demographic information, only anonymous usage statistics. To ensure that you are not tracked, we have blocked all embedded content from third party sources like YouTube and SlideShare. Click "Accept Cookies" to enable third-party content. To learn more about our cookie policy,click here.
Court Upholds Tiebacks as Permissible Permanent Support in 248 East 62nd Street Development LLC v. Golden Future, LLC
In May 2026, the New York Supreme Court, New York County, issued a notable decision in 248 East 62nd Street Development LLC v. Golden Future, LLC, which provides one of the first significant interpretations of the recently amended RPAPL § 881. The ruling addresses a question that developers, adjoining owners, and practitioners had been watching closely since the amendment took effect on December 5, 2025: whether courts would uphold the statute’s new language authorizing installations of support systems that had historically been challenged as impermissible permanent encroachments.
For years, developers seeking access to adjacent properties in connection with demolition and construction work often faced strong opposition when proposed support measures permanently extended into neighboring property. Adjoining owners frequently argued that permanent encroachments were beyond the scope of an RPAPL § 881 license, forcing project owners to redesign support plans, pursue alternative engineering solutions, and absorb additional cost and delay. As we noted in our prior alert discussing the 2025 amendment to RPAPL § 881, the revised statute appeared to expand the scope of permissible access by expressly authorizing certain foundation and building supports, including wall ties, tiebacks, anchors, straps, and underpinning. The 248 East 62nd Street decision offers notable guidance on how courts are applying that language to permanent tiebacks.
The 248 East 62nd Street Decision
In 248 East 62nd Street, the developer sought a license to access an adjacent historic townhouse in order to demolish its own building. The requested access included standard temporary protections and monitoring, as well as the installation of lateral tiebacks to support the neighboring wall. To accomplish this, the developer proposed installing C-channels on the face of the adjoining side of the party wall and drilling rods through. After construction of the new building, the C-channels would be removed, the rods torched down, and the wall patched so that the rods would no longer be visible from the adjoining property.
The adjoining owner opposed the petition on the ground that the tiebacks would remain permanently on its side of the party wall and therefore constituted an impermissible permanent encroachment and an unconstitutional taking. The developer argued that the new amendment of RPAPL § 881 expressly authorizes tiebacks and that such tiebacks are not unconstitutional because they would not be visible once torched down and patched.
The Court’s decision favored the developer’s argument, and the Court granted the license to install the tiebacks. Significantly, the court reasoned that, under the particular circumstances of the case, although the tiebacks would physically and permanently cross the property line, they would not diminish, block, or take away any usable portion of the neighbor’s dwelling or physical structure. On that basis, the court characterized the installation as a lawful permanent easement permitted by the amended statute rather than an unconstitutional taking. The Court also reasoned that the tiebacks were the “least restrictive alternative available to achieve structural safety.”
Future Considerations
Critically, the issue of compensation for permanent easements remains open. Although the Court granted the requested access, it initially referred compensation for the permanent easement to a special referee; on reargument, that reference was vacated and the Court will determine compensation itself. That issue has not yet been decided. As a result, while the decision provides meaningful guidance on the availability of this type of relief, it leaves unanswered the question of how courts will value compensation for permanent support installations authorized under the amended statute.
Furthermore, appellate review bears close watching. The adjoining owner filed a notice of appeal on June 16, 2026. Accordingly, the decision could still be narrowed, reversed, or otherwise addressed on appeal. If upheld, however, it may become an important precedent confirming that the 2025 amendment meaningfully expanded the range of support work available through RPAPL § 881.
For More Information
The Construction team at Tarter Krinsky & Drogin has extensive experience advising project owners and adjacent owners on RPAPL § 881 proceedings and negotiating access agreements, and we will continue to closely monitor how courts interpret and apply the amended statute as the case law develops. Please contact us with any questions or to discuss how this decision may impact your current or upcoming projects.